top of page

Synthetic Slate vs Metal Slate Roofing: How Do They Compare?

11 hours ago
6 min read

Both give you the slate look without the weight of stone, and both carry the top UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating. The real differences are weight, pitch and warranty. By the makers' own numbers, EcoStar's synthetic slate weighs "approximately 3lb. / sq. ft.," or about 300 pounds per 100 square foot roofing square, while ProVia's steel slate and shake panel weighs 106 pounds per square. EcoStar puts natural slate at 10 to 24 pounds per square foot.

 

Neither product earns a Class A fire rating on its own. EcoStar says a Class A roof uses GAF VersaShield underlayment "over the entire roof deck," DensDeck roof board or an EcoStar-approved alternate, and ProVia's installation guide says a Class A assembly needs "Firestone® CLAD-GARD SA-FR or similar code-specified underlayment." Order the wrong underlayment and you lose the rating the brochure promised. This guide compares materials, weight, ratings, pitch, warranties and roof-over rules.


CGR Wholesale Roofing

What Are Synthetic Slate and Metal Slate Made Of?

 

Synthetic slate is a molded polymer roof tile shaped and colored to look like quarried slate. EcoStar says its slate and shake tiles "are made of up to 80% recycled plastics and rubbers." Its Traditional Slate tile is 1/4 inch thick nominal, 18 inches long and comes in 6, 9, 10 and 12 inch widths, in "14 standard colors, 12 factory blends and unlimited custom colors."

 

ProVia's metal slate is steel. Its brochure lists "26-Gauge Steel" with a "G90 Zinc Galvanized Coating" and a Fluropon Kynar 500 (70% PVDF) base color and clear coat. Each panel covers 50 by 12 inches of exposure, with 24 panels per square, and ProVia's slate colors are Coalstone, Larkstone, Lodgestone, Ironstone and Baystone.

 

How Much Do Synthetic, Metal and Natural Slate Weigh?

 

Roofing

Weight, per the maker cited

Deck called for

EcoStar synthetic slate

About 3 lb per sq ft (about 300 lb per square)

1/2 in plywood (EcoStar sell sheet)

ProVia metal slate/shake panel

106 lb per square

Sheathing; screws must penetrate at least 1/2 in through it

Natural slate, per EcoStar

10 to 24 lb per sq ft

5/8 to 3/4 in plywood

Natural slate, per ProVia

800 to 1,500 lb per square

Not stated

 

Sources: EcoStar Synthetic vs. Natural sell sheet (2025); ProVia Slate & Shake installation guide (2/24) and metal roofing myths blog (updated July 2026).

 

Both lookalikes are a fraction of real slate, and metal is roughly a third of the synthetic tile by these figures. That gap matters on framing that was not built for heavy roofing. For natural slate, the Slate Roofing Contractors Association calls for a deck of at least "3/4" thick wood." EcoStar's installation guide sets its own minimum deck at 15/32 inch plywood, 7/16 inch OSB or 3/4 inch tongue and groove boards.

 

How Do They Compare on Hail, Fire and Wind?

 

Rating

EcoStar Traditional Slate

ProVia metal slate

Impact

UL 2218 Class 4

UL 2218 Class 4

Fire

UL 790 Class A or Class C (Class A needs VersaShield, DensDeck or an approved alternate)

Class A under ASTM E108 (assembly needs CLAD-GARD SA-FR or similar)

Wind

ASTM D3161 Class F; Miami-Dade TAS100 and TAS125

Class 30, 60 or 90 by screw count, up to 180 mph with 7 screws per panel

 

Sources: EcoStar Traditional Slate data sheet and product page; ProVia brochure and installation guide.

 

ProVia ties wind performance to fasteners: "4 screws per panel to achieve a Class 30 (120mph wind rating)," five for Class 60 (160 mph) and seven for Class 90 (180 mph). Buy screws for the rating you want. EcoStar lists a "110 mph Wind Warranty available." If hail is your main worry, CGR's post on whether a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle is worth it in PA explains the rating.

 

What Roof Pitch and Underlayment Does Each Need?

 

EcoStar says its tiles "are not recommended for slopes less than 3/12," and limits Traditional Slate to a 6 inch exposure from 3/12 up to 4/12. It calls for at least 30 lb felt (ASTM D226 Type II or D4869 Type IV) over the deck, with Glacier Guard or equal "applied to all eaves, rake edges, hips, valleys, ridges and protrusions."

 

ProVia's minimum recommended slope is 4:12 over Sharkskin Ultra underlayment and 3:12 over Sharkskin Ultra SA, and it says "underlayment is required prior to installing the ProVia metal roof system in both new and roofover applications."

 

For comparison, the 2021 IRC limits natural slate shingles to slopes of 4:12 or greater and metal roof shingles to 3:12 or greater. CGR's guide to understanding roof pitch shows how to measure yours.

 

Season matters for the synthetic tile. EcoStar's installation guide says its materials "should be installed at temps of 45°F (7°C) or greater" with ambient air "at least 34°F (1°C) and rising." A late fall job may need to wait for a warm stretch.

 

Which Has the Better Warranty?

 

They are built differently, so read both:

 

  • EcoStar: a standard "50-Year Limited Material Warranty" at no extra charge, "non-transferable," with no inspection. A "transferable 50-Year Gold Star Limited Labor & Material Warranty" requires an EcoStar Gold Star Certified Contractor and an inspection, costs "$10/sq charge or minimum $500," and is "transferable once in the first 7 years."

  • ProVia: a Lifetime Limited Warranty that is "non pro-rated" on material defects for the original homeowner, a "40-Year chalk and fade guarantee," and coverage that is "transferrable to subsequent owners."

 

If you may sell the house, the transfer terms are the line to compare. EcoStar's standard material warranty does not transfer; its Gold Star warranty transfers once in the first 7 years and requires a certified contractor, an inspection and a fee. ProVia's transfers to subsequent owners.

 

Can Either Go Over an Existing Shingle Roof?

 

ProVia says yes, where local code allows it: "Installation over existing asphalt shingle roofing is acceptable, when permitted by local building code," with "synthetic underlayment" installed over the shingles. At about 106 pounds per square, the panels add little load. Check the existing layers and deck condition with your code office first.

 

EcoStar's installation guide says "under all circumstances, existing roof materials must be removed down to the deck, prior to installation," so plan a tear-off for synthetic slate. CGR's comparison of metal roofing vs shingles for PA homes covers the broader tradeoffs.

 

Which One Fits Your House?

 

  • Weight-limited framing or a roof-over: ProVia metal slate.

  • A 3:12 roof: EcoStar at limited exposure, or ProVia over Sharkskin Ultra SA.

  • The widest color choice: EcoStar's 14 standard colors, 12 factory blends and custom colors.

  • Resale and transferable coverage: ProVia's transferable lifetime warranty, or EcoStar's paid Gold Star option.

 

Real slate is still the long-life benchmark. The National Park Service says slate roofs "will last 60 to 125 years or longer depending on the type of slate," with Pennsylvania soft-vein slates lasting "in excess of 60 years." CGR's post on how long a metal roof lasts covers metal's side of that comparison.

 

FAQ

 

Is synthetic slate as good as real slate?

 

It is far lighter and carries a Class 4 impact rating, but EcoStar's warranty runs 50 years, while the National Park Service says natural slate can last 60 to 125 years or longer.

 

Is metal slate roofing Class 4 impact rated?

 

ProVia's metal slate is rated UL 2218 Class 4, the same class EcoStar lists for its synthetic slate.

 

How much does synthetic slate weigh per square?

 

EcoStar lists about 3 pounds per square foot, which works out to roughly 300 pounds per 100 square foot square.

 

What is the minimum pitch for synthetic slate?

 

EcoStar does not recommend its tiles below 3/12 and limits exposure to 6 inches between 3/12 and 4/12.

 

Can metal slate go over shingles?

 

ProVia allows it when local code permits, with synthetic underlayment over the old shingles.

 

Do you need special underlayment for a Class A fire rating?

 

Yes, for both. EcoStar names GAF VersaShield, DensDeck or an EcoStar-approved alternate, and ProVia names Firestone CLAD-GARD SA-FR or similar code-specified underlayment.

 

Order EcoStar and ProVia Slate at CGR Wholesale

 

CGR Wholesale Roofing & Siding Supply Center carries EcoStar synthetic roofing, including synthetic slate and shake roof tiles, and now offers ProVia metal roofing in shake, slate and barrel tile styles. Ask about both lines at the Rostraver showroom, open Monday through Friday 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM and Saturday 7:00 AM to 12:00 PM, and bring your roof measurements and pitch so you can confirm the underlayment and fasteners each system requires.

 

Visit CGR Wholesale Roofing & Siding Supply Center or call 724-268-3671 today. Contact us for more information.


CGR Wholesale

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page