Is Vinyl Shake Siding Worth It for Gables and Accent Walls?
Often, yes. Shake siding brings a cedar look to a gable, dormer or accent wall "without the demanding maintenance associated with natural wood," as CGR's Foundry page puts it, but the brands differ more than the name suggests. CertainTeed Cedar Impressions is molded polypropylene that conforms to ASTM D7254, with a nominal wall thickness of .080 to .125 inch depending on the profile. Mastic Cedar Discovery, sold as vinyl, lists .080 to .100 inch. The Texas Department of Insurance lists Foundry premium vinyl siding at a nominal panel thickness of 0.040 inch.
The other thing to know is how cold weather changes the install. The industry installation manual, published by the Vinyl Siding Institute (now the Polymeric Exterior Products Association), says that for vinyl siding you should leave 1/4 inch at openings, corner posts and channels, and "increase minimum clearance to 3/8"" when installing below 40°F. For shakes and shingles, it defers to each maker. This guide compares the three brands, explains why shakes suit gables, and covers the cold-weather and gable install rules.

What Is Vinyl Shake Siding Made Of?
Shake siding is a molded panel shaped to look like rows of split cedar shakes or sawn cedar shingles. Not all of it is vinyl, even when it is sold as vinyl shake siding:
PVC (vinyl). Westlake Royal describes Foundry as "real cedar in durable PVC," and Florida's product approval for Foundry Staggered Shake lists the material as vinyl tested to ASTM D3679.
Polypropylene. CertainTeed's spec sheet lists Cedar Impressions as "Modified polypropylene copolymer," conforming to ASTM D7254.
Vinyl, per the maker. Mastic calls Cedar Discovery "premium shake and shingle vinyl siding."
The standards matter when you compare. The Polymeric Exterior Products Association certifies vinyl siding to ASTM D3679 and polypropylene siding to ASTM D7254, with "regular unannounced plant inspections" by an accredited third party.
How Thick Are Foundry, Cedar Impressions and Mastic Shakes?
Brand and line | Material | Thickness as published | Profiles named | Warranty | Wind rating |
CertainTeed Cedar Impressions | Polypropylene (ASTM D7254) | .080 to .125 in wall, by profile | Perfection, Staggered Perfection, Rough-Split, Sawmill, Perfection Shapes | Lifetime Limited, transferable | 37 to 231 psf design pressure, by profile |
Mastic Cedar Discovery | Vinyl | .080 to .100 in | Double 7 in Shingle, Half-Round, Hand-Split Shake, Triple 5 in Shingle | V.I.P. Limited Lifetime | Up to 218 mph ASD |
Foundry (Westlake Royal) | PVC (ASTM D3679) | 0.040 in nominal panel (TDI-listed profiles) | Perfection Shingle, Staggered Shake, Split Shake, Round, Fish Scale | Limited Lifetime | Up to 170 mph |
Foundry Grayne | Composite vinyl | 0.050 in | Grayne 5 in and 7.5 in Shingle | Not listed here | Not listed here |
Sources: CertainTeed spec sheet (01/2024) and ICC-ES listing ESL-1537 (March 2026); Ply Gem Mastic Cedar Discovery page and brochure (05/26); Texas Department of Insurance report EC-93; Westlake Royal Foundry brochure (1/25).
Each source measures a little differently. CertainTeed reports wall thickness by profile, ICC-ES lists its nail flange at 0.090 to 0.125 inch, and the Texas report gives Foundry's nominal panel thickness. Compare the published specs side by side before you choose.
Why Use Shake Siding on Gables and Accent Walls?
Shakes work as an accent as well as a full wall. CGR's Foundry page says its styles suit "complete exterior installations, gables, dormers, accent walls, and other architectural details." Westlake Royal says Foundry panels come from "molds cast from real wood shakes and shingles," with "72 unique shake or shingle designs spread over eight panels."
Shapes add another option. CertainTeed's ICC-ES listing includes Perfection Shapes in Scallop, Octagon and Half-Cove, and Foundry offers round and fish scale profiles.
Plan the trim with the panel. Foundry's brochure calls for a 3/4 inch J-channel with its shingle and round profiles and a 1 inch J-channel with Split Shake and Staggered Shake. Its Fullback foam shims are 0.5 inch thick and call for a 1-1/2 inch J-channel. For matching trim around the gable, see CGR's guide to matching Mastic trim coil to siding colors.
What Changes When You Install Shake Siding in Cold Weather?
Polymer siding moves with temperature, and cold weather changes the gaps. The installation manual says vinyl siding "can expand and contract 1/2" (12.7mm) or more over a 12' 6" (3.81m) length." Its rules for vinyl siding, which shake makers' own sheets may adjust:
Leave 1/4 inch clearance at openings, corner posts and channels, and increase it to 3/8 inch below 40°F.
Do not nail tight. Leave "approximately 1/32" (0.8mm) clearance (the thickness of a dime)" under the fastener head.
"In extremely cold weather, move the saw through the material slowly to prevent chipping or cracking."
Siding cut on a cold November day will expand in summer heat, which is why the extra 1/8 inch matters.
How Is Shake Siding Installed in a Gable?
The industry manual says to install J-channel "to receive the siding at the gable ends" first, then "make a pattern that duplicates the slope of the gable." For shakes and shingles, it tells installers to "check specific manufacturer for their installation techniques," and polypropylene should be installed "according to the manufacturer's instructions."
Mastic's Cedar Discovery tip sheet gives a typical example:
"Allow 1/4" gap at all corner posts, J-Channel, or other stops."
"Nail through center of slots every 8"" and "do not fasten tight."
On gables, "measure panel from right end of nail hem (L) and cut at correct angle."
Install over "a solid nailable sheathing, such as plywood or OSB."
For Foundry, the Texas report lists 1-1/2 inch galvanized smooth shank roofing nails with at least a 7/16 inch head and says "all fasteners must be corrosion resistant." Order fasteners with the siding so the job does not stall.
Is Vinyl Shake Siding Worth It for Your Project?
It depends on what you want from the gable:
The highest published thickness and shaped profiles: CertainTeed Cedar Impressions, at up to .125 inch wall thickness on Rough-Split profiles.
A vinyl shake at mid-range thickness with a high wind rating: Mastic Cedar Discovery, at .080 to .100 inch and up to 218 mph ASD.
Many cedar patterns plus round or fish scale accents: Foundry, with 72 designs per profile.
If you are matching existing siding, compare a scrap of the old siding with the maker's current color chart before you order. CGR's posts on the most popular siding colors in 2026, board and batten siding and CertainTeed vs ProVia siding cover other accent options.
FAQ
Is vinyl shake siding vinyl or polypropylene?
It depends on the brand. Foundry is PVC tested to the vinyl standard ASTM D3679, Mastic calls Cedar Discovery vinyl, and CertainTeed Cedar Impressions is polypropylene to ASTM D7254.
How thick is shake siding?
CertainTeed lists .080 to .125 inch by profile, Mastic lists .080 to .100 inch, and the Texas Department of Insurance lists Foundry at 0.040 inch nominal panel thickness.
Is Foundry siding PVC?
Yes. Westlake Royal Building Products describes Foundry as "real cedar in durable PVC."
Can you use shake siding just on the gables?
Yes. CGR's Foundry page lists gables, dormers and accent walls among its uses, and CertainTeed and Foundry both offer shaped profiles.
Can you install shake siding in cold weather?
Yes, with care. For vinyl siding, the industry manual raises the minimum clearance from 1/4 inch to 3/8 inch below 40°F and says to cut slowly in extreme cold, but for shakes and shingles it says to follow each maker's instructions.
Is the Cedar Impressions warranty transferable?
Yes. CertainTeed says its Lifetime Limited Warranty "is transferable if the home is sold."
Find Shake Siding at CGR Wholesale
CGR Wholesale Roofing & Siding Supply Center carries several Foundry siding styles, including Staggered Shake, Split Shake, Perfection Shingle, Rounded Shingle and Grayne Shingle. Its Mastic siding page includes Mastic Shake & Shingle, and its CertainTeed siding page lists Cedar Impressions Perfection, Rough-Split and Sawmill. The Contractor Corner in West Mifflin, which serves contractors, lists Mastic trim coil in .019 and .024 gauge "In All Colors." Bring your gable measurements to the Rostraver showroom, open Monday through Friday 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM and Saturday 7:00 AM to 12:00 PM, or call in an order for pickup or delivery.
Visit CGR Wholesale Roofing & Siding Supply Center or call 724-268-3671 today. Contact us for more information.






Comments